Wittgenstein’s Poker, Reconsidered

9th March 2027, 6.30-7.30pm

In this members-only talk, Dr David Edmonds will revisit and reflect on his 2001 best-seller, Wittgenstein’s Poker.

In 1946, Karl Popper, newly arrived in the UK, was invited to talk to the Cambridge Moral Science Club and asked to bring a philosophical ‘puzzle’.  But Popper didn’t believe in puzzles.  He believed in problems.  He entitled his talk, ‘Are there philosophical problems?’.  Ludwig Wittgenstein was the chair of the Moral Science Club, and the meeting – on October 25th – was the only occasion the two Viennese-born philosophers ever met.  Did Wittgenstein get so annoyed that he waved a fireside poker at Popper?  Did Popper lie about the episode?  And why was the atmosphere so fierce?  Twenty-five years ago, David Edmonds co-wrote Wittgenstein’s Poker (with John Eidinow).  It focused on the Wittgenstein-Popper 10-minute interaction – and became an unlikely best-seller.  In this talk, David revisits the poker episode; would he, were he writing today, reach the same verdict?

This talk is for members only: you can find out more about becoming a TRIP member here.

About the Speaker:

David Edmonds is a Distinguished Research Fellow at the Oxford Uehiro Institute and a former BBC journalist.  He is the author or editor of many critically acclaimed philosophy books (and one on chess) which together have been translated into 30 languages.  These include (with John Eidinow) Wittgenstein’s Poker (enthusiastically promoted by Bill Clinton), Would You Kill The Fat Man?, Parfit: A Philosopher and his Mission to Save Morality, and Death In A Shallow Pond.  He has written articles for many publications, including The New Statesman and Prospect.  He also co-hosts (with Nigel Warburton) Philosophy Bites which has had over 50 million downloads. He was once in the Guinness Book of Records for his part in the creation of the world’s largest Jaffa Cake.  Annoyingly, this record has since been surpassed.